Stefan
Ruzowitzsky’s The Counterfeiters is a beautifully layered
drama. To call this a “historical reenactment” or a “World War
II film” would be doing a grave disservice to the notable
intellect and emotion behind the work. While The
Counterfeiters may take place in a Nazi concentration camp,
it bears little in common with the image that one typically
associates with the setting. This is a film about the complex
moral dilemmas of a group of individuals who were indeed
oppressed by Hitler’s brutal regime, but not through mass
genocide. Sure, the characters imprisoned in the picture are
aware of the fact that the Nazis could kill them at any moment
and that the group is actively massacring other people of their
religious faith. But, for the most part, The Counterfeiters
side-skirts the immediate threat of bloodshed in favor of
shining a light on one of the more psychological ways in which
Nazis destroyed innocent human lives.
The film is
based on a true story that took place during the mid-1930s in
World War II-dominated Europe. Its protagonist is German Salomon
“Sally” Sorowitsch (Karl Markovics) who, the viewer learns, was
once considered the world’s greatest counterfeiter. Money,
passports, identification cards, you name it – Sally and his
team of experts could copy it. When the Nazis took him prisoner
(he was Jewish), they realized that they could use Sally to
execute a massive-scale counterfeiting plan. This plan came to
be headed by Heinrich Himmler himself, and its main mission was
to successfully create tamper-proof replicas of the British
Pound and the American Dollar. The Nazis believed that, if they
could manufacture enough of these currencies, they could flood
the economies of Great Britain and the United States and thereby
successfully take over the Western World. Sally was provided a
massive team of other prisoners so that he was able to
counterfeit the money and, as a gift for working on the project,
he and his men were afforded many luxuries that most prisoners
of concentration camps would never dream of.
Despite the
grand consequences of the characters’ actions in The
Counterfeiters, the film’s content is handled with a
stunningly restrained amount of intimacy. The movie’s central
theme regards the morality of Sally and company’s actions. Is it
right that they are helping the Nazis in order to save
themselves from systematic execution and to live in conditions
that will prevent them from becoming malnourished or diseased?
One of Sally’s workers, Adolf Burger (August Diehl), does not
believe so, and eventually jeopardizes the group’s safety by
refusing to carry out his very-important role in the operation.
(The film is actually based off of Burger’s autobiography,
despite the fact that he is presented as a supporting character
in it.)
The
aforementioned moral dilemma permeates through every scene in
the picture. Viewers are able to see both sides of the issue,
heartbreakingly realizing that these men shouldn’t have to make
the decision that the Nazis have forced them to come to terms
with. In this respect, The Counterfeiters is equally as
effective as most serious, violent dramas about the Holocaust
are, quietly sneaking up on the viewer in a manner that allows
them to fully understand the solemn consequences of the Nazis’
injustices.
The
performances of Markovics and Diehl greatly aid in making the
film the emotionally affecting work that it is. Both actors make
sure to create characters who understand one another; Sally and
Adolf are never meant to seem like rivals, just men who react to
an extraordinary situation differently. Sally’s sense of
responsibility for his established troupe, perfectly depicted by
Markovics, makes him feel the need to continue the
counterfeiting operation. Adolf, on the other hand, understands
the greater context of the situation and believes that it would
be selfish of him to do the same. Both actors are remarkably
subtle in their approaches, but entirely brilliant in creating
equally empathetic figures. A scene in the film’s final act
(which I need not spoil) involving the counterfeiters’ reaction
to a group of “real” concentration camp prisoners is
particularly effective in showing the consequences of Sally and
Adolf’s points of view. This scene is handled by Markovics and
Diehl with a crowning degree of emotional authenticity.
The
Counterfeiters is entirely engrossing not only for its
realistic depiction of actual events, but for its narrative
unpredictability. Despite the considerable amount of historical
content that it offers viewers, the film feels more like a work
of cinema than a Social Studies lesson, thereby increasing its
power as both. Viewers unfamiliar with the story (as I was) will
find themselves on the edge of their seats as they watch the
plot’s events unfold through cinematographer Benedict Neuenfels’
gritty, zooming lens. For both its enlightening telling of a
little-known part of a devastating time in human history and its
notable filmic richness, The Counterfeiters is a terrific
motion picture.