Tamara Jenkins’ The
Savages might not carry the gravest of tones, but it deals with a
topic of profound emotional heft: the deterioration of a
parent’s health. Despite its success as a black comedy and
its uplifting messages about the miracle that is life,
there’s no denying that this is a sad, sad movie. Still,
the difference between The Savages and the average
tearjerker of this sort is the warmth and humanity
displayed by its characters. Not only is this the reason
that the movie’s subtle sense of humor is able to work
effectively, it is also why the movie succeeds as a drama.
Jenkins has given filmgoers a motion picture that they can
really be thankful for this Holiday season, one that never
skirts around the hard truths of life but understands them
with such compassion that it is impossible not to embrace.
Jon (Philip
Seymour Hoffman) and Wendy Savage (Laura Linney) don’t
know what to do with their ailing father Lenny (Philip
Bosco), who is slowly dying of Dementia. Lenny’s
girlfriend of many years has just kicked the bucket and,
having signed an agreement revoking any ownership rights
he might normally have established over her home or
property (“a pre-nup without the nup,” as Jon understands
it), he has nowhere to go and no one to take care of him.
After much debate between Jon and Wendy, who have not been
in regular contact with each other for years and find it
hard to agree on anything, Lenny is moved from his prior
residence of Sun City, Arizona to a nursing home near
Jon’s Buffalo, New York home. As Lenny’s condition
deteriorates, his son and daughter forge a bond that makes
them feel closer to each other than they ever had been
before.
Lenny’s
devastating condition is not atypical for a man of his
age, but this does not make it any less tragic. Jenkins
rightfully does not shy away from this truth, depicting
the man’s medical problems in unflinching detail from the
get-go. In one of the first scenes in the film (when
Lenny’s girlfriend is still alive), the viewer is forced
to confront the severity of Lenny’s case of Dementia. When
his girlfriend’s pompous caregiver asks him to flush his
excrement down their toilet, which he had neglected to do,
Lenny becomes enraged at the man’s carelessness and
smothers the feces all over the bathroom wall. It is a
harrowing sequence, with a great amount of power resting
in Bosco’s stunningly realistic performance. Equal
poignancy is achieved in a later scene, in which Lenny
finally realizes that the nursing home he is staying in is
not a hotel, as he had assumed, when Jon asks him if he
would like to be buried or cremated when he dies.
As much as The
Savages may have to say about the American medical
system, it functions primarily as a touchingly human tale.
After all, Lenny is just a supporting character who
fulfills a predictable path as the film progresses. It is
Jon and Wendy who are the lifeblood of the film’s story,
the individuals who the viewer relates to and seeks solace
in. In this regard, The Savages is something of a
minor-masterpiece, mainly because of the perfect presence
of Hoffman and Linney in the roles. Even if the two actors
aren’t the manically depressed people that their
characters are, the viewer can’t help but find so much of
Hoffman and Linney’s own personalities incorporated in Jon
and Wendy. As a result, The Savages becomes very
easy to connect with and, in turn, to discover a bit of
oneself in. Whether this quality is a testament to the
leads’ abilities as actors or to casting director Jeanne
McCarthy’s knack for picking them, I dunno, but it doesn’t
really matter. As moviegoers, we can simply be grateful to
know that Hoffman and Linney found these roles and made
them their own.
As depressing as
my description of The Savages may make the movie
sound, I must assure you that it is as much a
crowd-pleaser as it is a serious drama. For audiences to
assume that the film’s subject-matter makes it an entirely
unbearable experience would be a grave mistake. As I
previously hinted, Jenkins’ deep realization of Jon and
Wendy’s characters allows for some terrifically-written
dark humor to surface in the situations that they find
themselves in. In fact, The Savages boasts a few
laugh-out-loud sequences that will momentarily make the
audience forget the work’s pervading melancholy. In
addition, the film finishes amidst a beautifully pro-life
message, ultimately leaving said audience appreciative of
life’s many beauties. Grim as it sometimes may seem,
The Savages will find its way into the hearts and
minds of viewers, resonating in a manner that is both
poignant and gentle.