Home | Reviews | Exclusive Writings | Great Links | Miscellaneous | FAQ | Contact Us

Review for the Week of 2/1 (Just a Bit Late):

Girl With A Pearl Earring



Rated PG-13 | 95 mins


     Did you see what I saw? Yeah, isn’t that weird? It couldn’t be, could it?

     Girl with a Pearl Earring has just about everything going against it as there is possible. It shouldn’t work—plain and simple—but it does. There is a mesmerizing plot, even though nothing really happens in it. We’re attached to the characters, despite the fact that we’ve been introduced to them with hardly any background. I don’t know if this is a failure on the part of director Peter Webber, or an extraordinary achievement. However, the picture is a beautiful, moody piece, bursting with elegance in every corner and crack of its contents.

     The story tells us of Griet (Scarlett Johansson), a servant girl who finds work in the house of painter Johannes Vermeer (Colin Firth). She rarely sees Johannes at first, mostly because of the close watch his stern and prim mother-in-law, Maria Thins (Judy Parfitt) has over the house. But, Griet cleans his studio each day, never moving any of the contents in it an inch, as instructed. Johansson glances around at his work, and we read her expressions, captivated by Griet in the same way she is with the work of Vermeer.

     From the second she first steps into the presence of her gifted employer, his relationship with her is constantly intriguing and uncertain. He has a desire for Griet; is it love, inspiration, respect? Johannes’ thoughts are made clearer as the picture comes to a close, but the hypnotizing finale still leaves much to perpend, concluding in a manner which allows the film to linger in viewers’ minds until they are confident in their interpretation of it.

     When the picture reaches its crescendo, Johannes paints a portrait of Griet. It’s a poignant and wonderful moment of truth; one’s response to it will solely depend on the way they relate to Griet and her surroundings in the movie.

     Webber allows Girl with a Pearl Earring to unfold meditatively, utilizing a key sense of visual poetry, in order to overshadow any murky and unsettling details regarding character’s motivation. Even though I think the ambivalence of the plot would be just fine if the story were told in a less flashy way, the methodic feel the director utilizes makes audiences have a distinct mindset, which will undeniably make them pay attention to detail.

     The film plays out like true historical fiction should (emphasis on fiction). It was adapted by screenwriter Olivia Hetreed from Tracy Chevalier’s novel, which was originally based upon the real Vermeer painting, going after the same title as the movie.

     The details about the life of the model in the painting are sketchy; her relationship to the artist isn’t even known. Johansson, though, could simply be a clone of her, transported forward in time. She’s not only practically identical to Vermeer’s subject, but delivers the second best female performance of 2003 (the best being her work in Lost in Translation), as well. Even with literally no dialogue, Johansson peers at the world in a way we can completely understand and relate to.

     The earth that the characters in Girl with a Pearl Earring inhabit has a surreal gloss to it. It’s certainly not a wonderful place to be, in the least bit. But, considering my reaction to the film, I am confident that most everyone else will be just as eager to be transported into the setting as I was. This is a marvelous picture that does something special: creates a story with little background, and leaves us captivated by it.


Back to Home
The Bucket Review's Rating Scale