Catch-Up Capsule Reviews for Films Released the Weekend of 4/11/08:
Prom Night is technically a remake of a 1980 Jamie Lee
Curtis feature of the same name but, in truth, the only two traits that
it bears in common with that film are its high school-prom setting and
its membership-card to the slasher-horror genre. In fact, the movie is
far more similar to another recent re-imagining of a Curtis picture: Rob
Zombie’s Halloween. While director Nelson McCormick and writer
J.S. Cardone don’t take body-count here to the offensive height that
Zombie did in his film, Prom Night follows exactly the same
structure as Zombie’s effort: 1) a teenage girl will be endangered if a
certain bad man who wants to do bad things to her escapes from jail, 2)
the bad man unexpectedly does escape from jail and, 3) the girl
must do everything that her illogical, ditzy brain will allow to stay
alive as the bad man chases after her. Oh, wait, did I just summarize
the plot of nearly every teen-targeted horror picture released in recent
years? Perhaps I was a little short-sighted in making the aforementioned
Halloween comparison: Prom Night is just like every other
recent entry into its genre. Sure, the movie is too benign and
predictable in its delivery for the viewer to find it even the least bit
objectionable. And sure, it has a few good qualities, Brittany Snow’s
sympathetic lead performance being the best of them. But who really
cares? We’ve all seen this movie before and we’ll surely see it again.
Unless you’re a thirteen-year-old girl who will be scared by and
involved in drivel of the utmost tepidity, there’s absolutely no reason
for you to see Prom Night.
The rising popularity of the Independent Film has done a whole lot
of good for the cause of providing thoughtful alternatives to mainstream
cinema, but it has also taken its toll on the indie filmmaker’s sense of
creativity. Instead of looking for new ways to invent, mold, and rework
the conventions of the medium of film as we know it—this is the whole
purpose of working without a studio, it seems to me—a growing percentage
of independent writers and directors have begun to copy the practices of
the studio-system by regurgitating the plots and characters of popular
indies that have come before. Case in point is Smart People, a
movie that desperately wants to be like Little Miss Sunshine and
Sideways but doesn’t have half of the brains of either film. Yes,
Smart People makes some attempts to mock the success of those
pictures by creating a dysfunctional family-based story and employing a
cast of actors who boast big names but are fond of tackling small
projects—Dennis Quaid, Thomas Haden Church, Sarah Jessica Parker, and
Ellen Page—but it fails on nearly every count. The characterizations
found in Smart People are muddled and the dialogue isn’t
particularly special. In fact, many of the film’s story threads seem to
have been made intentionally vague simply because they could then later
be deemed “edgy” or “up for interpretation” by amateur critics whose
comments could in turn appear on promotional materials. In fact, the
only real remnant of good to be found in the picture is Page’s
performance, which does back-flips around the work of the rest of the
cast-members, who appear to be sleepwalking through their roles for most
of the duration. One thing’s for sure: Smart People is nowhere
near as intelligent as its title would like to suggest.
As often as life in the
American ghetto is irrationally glamorized by contemporary filmmakers,
there remains a rugged, bleak form of visual poetry to be found in the
setting. Filmmaker David Ayer depicted this with stunning authenticity
in his script for the 2001 cop-drama, Training Day, and has since
returned for second-helpings with Street Kings, this time in the
director’s chair. Unfortunately, he sacrifices all of the drama, fear,
corruptness, and community found in his South Central L.A.-backdrop
during this outing in order to mold it into a routine cop-drama.
Street Kings may contain many of the same locales as Training Day,
but you wouldn’t know it based on the generic manner in which they are
depicted. Ayer’s screenplay could’ve been slapped into any location—even
the rich, near-crime-free zone of Los Angeles’ Beverly Hills—and
retained the same daytime-television-level of tension that it boasts
now. Yes, there are some interesting twists and turns made by the plot
of Ayer’s tale of L.A.P.D. corruption, but there’s not much of a reason
for the viewer to care about these when they belong to a soulless,
underdeveloped whole. Perhaps the greatest sin committed by Street
Kings is that it wastes the talents of its all-star cast—headlined
by Keanu Reeves, Forest Whitaker, Hugh Laurie, Chris Evans, and Cedric
the Entertainer—on such a manufactured story and one-dimensional set of
characters. Skip it.
Back to Home
The Bucket Review's Rating Scale
|